From the flash of SONIC’s Unicorn Dream Slush to the crunch of McDonald’s McCrispy Strips, food taste-testing often brings moments of delight—but few products have earned such cult-favorite status as Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches, now available in bulk at Costco.
The Virginia-based brand has recently captured dessert lovers’ attention with an exclusive 18-pack of its Strawberry Shortcake ice cream sandwiches, igniting a frenzy of fans who cleared out freezers nationwide. It’s not the first time Nightingale has caused a Costco craze—last year’s 18-pack of Cookie Monster sandwiches sold out within days.
After securing the Strawberry Shortcake variety, I dove deep into the rest of the Nightingale lineup to answer one very important question: which flavor is the absolute best? While I didn’t manage to snag every single offering (the classics like Key Lime Pie, Miso Churro, and Chocolate French Roast eluded me), I sampled enough to crown a top three. Whether you’re a Costco regular or just browsing for the latest ice cream franchise trend, here’s what you need to try.
3. Banana Pudding
Move aside, Magnolia Bakery—there’s a new banana pudding champ in town. This sandwich tastes uncannily like homemade banana bread, thanks to soft brown sugar cookies and rich banana pudding ice cream swirled with crushed vanilla wafers. It’s a nostalgic dessert done with gourmet flair—two types of cookies, one incredible bite.
2. Strawberry Shortcake
Costco’s current exclusive, this fruity gem makes a compelling case for summer’s best frozen dessert. Sandwiched between buttery sugar cookies is a light, creamy strawberry ice cream that balances fresh berry flavor with a rich texture. Even fruit-skeptics will be impressed—this flavor delivers pure, sun-soaked satisfaction.
1. Mocha Brownie
The winner—and it’s not even close. Mocha Brownie nails the perfect balance between chocolate decadence and coffee sophistication. Fudgy brownie cookies hug velvety vanilla ice cream infused with Blanchard’s locally roasted coffee. It’s like an affogato you can eat with one hand. Whether you’re a sweet-tooth purist or a fan of elevated desserts, this one is a must-try.
With inventive flavors and top-tier ingredients, Nightingale isn’t just another trendy brand—it’s redefining what frozen treats can be. Whether you’re exploring ice cream franchise opportunities or just searching for your next freezer staple, these sandwiches set a new standard in handheld indulgence.
Related topics
- Glover’s Ice Cream Marks 100 Sweet Years in Indiana
- Best Ice Cream in Jaipur: Top Picks from Local Food Experts
- Matcha Ice Cream: Flavor Trend and Franchise Potential
