As Americans scoop up their favorite frozen treats this summer, new research is raising serious questions about a common but little-known ingredient in many supermarket ice creams: emulsifiers.
Designed to enhance texture, improve shelf stability, and prevent melting under hot lights, emulsifiers like polysorbate 80, carrageenan, and carboxymethyl cellulose are present in thousands of foods — especially ultraprocessed ones, including popular ice cream brands. But recent studies suggest these additives may come at a hidden cost to gut health.
Mounting Evidence of Risk
Scientific studies increasingly point to a troubling link between emulsifiers and disruptions in the gut microbiome — the ecosystem of bacteria critical to digestion and overall health. Findings suggest that emulsifiers may:
Damage the gastrointestinal lining
Trigger inflammation
Contribute to conditions such as Crohn’s disease, ulcerative colitis, and even cancer
Despite these findings, much of the evidence comes from animal studies or lab simulations, leaving regulators and consumers in a gray area.
Still, anecdotal reports, like that of genetic scientist Lewis Rands, are hard to ignore. Rands said eliminating emulsifiers from his diet significantly eased debilitating symptoms tied to inflammatory bowel disease — a change that, for him, was “more effective than any drug.”
FDA Lagging Behind Science
Food and Drug Administration (FDA) standards historically focused on immediate toxicity, not long-term impacts on the microbiome. With the human gut now understood as a complex and powerful regulator of health, experts like former FDA commissioner Robert Califf argue the agency’s approach needs updating.
“There was no way to do it before,” Califf said. “But now, we have the tools.”
Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has flagged emulsifiers as part of a broader push to phase out harmful food additives — particularly petroleum-based compounds. But emulsifiers, derived from both natural and synthetic sources, present a thornier challenge.
Difficult to Avoid
Avoiding emulsifiers is no simple task. Products from Ben & Jerry’s to Healthy Choice often contain multiple types, sometimes under obscure names like mono- and diglycerides, maltodextrin, or xanthan gum. Even natural or organic-labeled foods aren’t exempt.
In contrast, some brands — like Häagen-Dazs — are marketing their products as free of emulsifiers. And for ice cream consumers seeking a cleaner option, such transparency may become a growing selling point.
Franchise & Brand Takeaways
As research develops and consumer awareness grows, the ice cream industry — particularly emerging ice cream franchise opportunities — may face a pivotal moment. Brands that proactively reformulate recipes or highlight additive-free ingredients could gain a competitive edge, especially with health-conscious and label-savvy shoppers.
In the meantime, as the science evolves, one thing is clear: ice cream may never look (or melt) the same again.
Related topics
- Dove Launches Two New Ice Cream Flavors — Plus a Chance to Get a Free Box
- Ultimate Guide to Milkshakes: History, Types, and Recipes
- IANR to Host Ice Cream Social Honoring Vice Chancellor Mike Boehm
